AN INDEPENDENT PERSPective


 It's so important to be true to yourself            "
khaliladis.com
  • Home
  • About
  • Blog
  • Books
  • Services
  • Media
  • Events
  • Awards/Accolades
  • Clients
  • Portfolio
  • Contact
  • Corporate Responsibility

How PR1MA went from a noble aspiration to provide affordable housing to a colossal failure

5/8/2019

0 Comments

 
The federal government mooted project had promised to build 1 million affordable homes by 2020. However, the project was from the beginning mired in controversies.


By Khalil Adis
Picture
Residensi Brickfields is one of PR1MA's strategic project location in the heart of KL. Photo: Screengrab from PR1MA.
Just last week, it was announced in the media that Perbadanan PR1MA Malaysia, a public housing agency which was established under the Barisan Nasional government may be dissolved as it is in a “mess”. The final decision on whether PR1MA projects should be continued is pending a due diligence report, which is expected to be completed end of this month.


For years, the PR1MA initiative has received lashbacks from various stakeholders and the general public for its inefficient implementation. 


I recall researching about PR1MA when I was writing my second book.  

The 1Malaysia People’s Housing Programme or PR1MA was launched in July 2011 and incorporated under the PR1MA Act in 2012. It became operational in March 2013 and to qualify, applicants will need to have a single or combined household income of between RM2,500 to RM15,000 per month.


I couldn’t help thinking how the hoopla around an announced PR1MA initiative usually fizzles out after some time, with no proper project updates disseminated to the public. 


For instance, under Budget 2016 that the government promised that it will build 5,000 units of houses under PR1MA and 1Malaysia Civil Servants Housing Programme (PPA1M) in 10 locations in the vicinities of light rail transit and monorail stations, including in Pandan Jaya, Sentul and Titiwangsa.


However, a quick check on PR1MA’s website does not show any such projects except for one in Brickfields, Fraser Business Park and Bukit Jalil respectively. 

​In addition, my interviews with young Malaysians while taking Grab and Uber show a great mismatch in what the government is saying – where many had said they had applied for the housing scheme, but they have yet to receive any official reply from PR1MA.

Here are some circumstances that may have led to PR1MA’s failure


#1: Lack of single housing agency to manage the affordable housing market
Picture
Affordable homes located near to Cochrane MRT station. Photo: Khalil Adis Consultancy.
Unlike Singapore which has the Housing & Development Board (HDB) to oversee the affordable housing segment, in Malaysia, there are many agencies rolling it out under the federal and state umbrellas.

From federal-led initiatives like PR1MA and Residensi Wilayah (RUMAWIP) to state-led schemes like Rumah Mampu Biaya Johor (RMBJ) and Rumah Selangorku, this not only confuses the public but leads to inefficient use of public resources competing for the same market.

What would work in my opinion is to have a single housing agency to streamline the entire process across the nation.

This could also allow the agency to gauge demand from the public via available government data.

In addition, this will allow them to allocate land according to demand to ensure that they are successfully balloted and fully taken up like the Singapore model.

The Ministry of Housing and Local Government had studied the HDB model last year and is reportedly looking to emulate it.


#2: Federal versus state government complicates matters
Picture
A Malaysian flag as seen at a shophouse in Negri Sembilan. Photo: Khalil Adis Consultancy.
While on paper this may sound ideal, it is not so easy in reality as land is a state matter.

As such, federal-initiated programmes like PR1MA will likely face bureaucratic red tapes and are less likely to receive priority when applying for the release of state land.​

YB Zuraida Kamaruddin, Minister of Housing and Local Government (KPKT) recently shared that it is the responsibility of the state governments to offer up their spacious lands for the development of affordable housing. However, as of end-2018, only 27 plot of lands out of the total 127 for affordable housing projects around the country, were supplied by state governments.

Let’s not forget that the state and federal governments may have different objectives which can further complicate matters.

#3: Costly to acquire land
Picture
Aerial view of Iskandar Puteri. Photo: Khalil Adis Consultancy.
Considering the challenge in securing land from respective state governments, the federal government would have to acquire them from private parties at a hefty cost.


As land cost takes up a significant percentage of a project’s cost, this will inevitably drive up the cost of building affordable homes.


Thus, it is hardly surprising that previous PR1MA projects were mostly built in undesirable locations, where homebuyer demand is low.

#4: Far-flung location with sub-par connectivity
Picture
IOI Puchong Jaya is one example of patchy connectivity from IOI Puchong Jaya LRT station. Photo: Khalil Adis Consultancy.
Hence why, one of the common grouses about PR1MA is the project’s far-flung location away from the city.


With the exception of the homes within KL mentioned above, most of PR1MA’s housing projects are inaccessible and will require applicants to own a car.


This then defeats the purpose of building affordable homes as most of the applicants will be financially burdened with the double whammy of a car and home loan.


Given Malaysia’s patchy connectivity and lack of seamless connection to public transport, this thus makes some of PR1MA’s projects highly unpopular.

#5: Some applicants were left in the dark
Picture
Attendees at iProperty.com Expo in 2017 at The Curve. Photo: Khalil Adis Consultancy.
The applicants are the most important stakeholders for PR1MA. 

As such, communication ought to be done more diligently.

Many young Malaysians I had spoken to said they did not receive any form of acknowledgement on the status of their application.

Some have been waiting for more than five years and are still waiting.

I had highlighted this at a panel discussion but a representative from PR1MA replied that this wasn’t true.

Perhaps, she had reasons to as this was during Najib Razak’s era.

Looking back, if this wasn’t the case, surely PR1MA would not be in its current position right now.

In addition, it would certainly help if PR1MA were to address these issues head-on to assure applicants.

Conclusion

Picture
Aerial view of Kuala Lumpur. Photo: Khalil Adis Consultancy.
Whether or not PR1MA will be dissolved remains to be seen.

However, PR1MA is already costing Malaysian taxpayers more than RM8 billion.
0 Comments



Leave a Reply.

    Khalil Adis

    An independent analysis from yours truly

    Archives

    December 2024
    February 2024
    January 2024
    July 2023
    June 2023
    May 2023
    April 2023
    January 2023
    December 2022
    November 2022
    August 2022
    July 2022
    April 2022
    March 2022
    January 2022
    November 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    June 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    September 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    December 2016

    Categories

    All
    121 Residences
    ABSD
    Affordable Homes
    Airbnb
    Allianz Real Estate
    Ang Mo Kio
    Astaka
    Astaka Holdings Limited
    Avenue South Residence
    Aviation Park
    Bandar Malaysia
    Bank Negara Malaysia
    Bayan Lepas LRT Line
    Bedok
    Below Market Value Property
    Branded Residences
    Bright Hill
    BTO Flats
    Budget 2019
    Budget 2020
    Bukit Chagar
    Bukit Panjang
    Cagamas Berhad
    Cairnhill 16
    Causeway Point
    Cheonggyecheon
    Chinatown Kuala Lumpur
    Circle Line
    City Plaza
    Cochrane MRT Station
    COVID19
    CPF
    Cross Island Line
    Defu
    En-bloc
    Energy Saving Tips
    Estate Planning
    Excelsior International School
    Family Violence
    First Home
    Foon Yew High School
    Forest City
    Geylang Serai
    Geylang Serai Bazaar
    GlaxoSmithKline
    Glomac Berhad
    Government Land Sales (GLS) Programme
    Greater Southern Waterfront
    HDB
    Health City Novena
    Heng Swee Keat
    High Speed Rail
    Home Mortgage
    Home Ownership Campaign 2019
    Home Renovation
    Home Rental
    Hougang
    Ibrahim International District
    IKEA Cheras
    Imperial Jade Residenz
    Interior Design
    Iskandar Halal Park
    Iskandar Malaysia
    Iskandar Regional Development Authority
    JB Food Trail
    JB-Woodlands RTS Link
    Johor Bahru
    Johor Bahru City Council
    Johor Bahru City Square
    Johor Property
    Johor Real Estate
    Joint Tenancy
    Joo Chiat Complex
    JPPH
    Jurong Lake District
    Jurong Regional Line
    Jurong West
    Keppel REIT
    Khaw Boon Wan
    KLCC
    KOMTAR JBCC
    KTM Terminal Skypark
    Kuala Lumpur Property
    Kuala Lumpur Real Estate
    Land Transport Authority
    LED Lighting
    Lim Guan Eng
    London Property Market
    London Real Estate
    Loyang
    LRT Bandar Utama-Klang Line (Klang Valley LRT Line 3)
    Malaysia Property
    Malaysia Real Estate
    Masterskill University College Of Health Sciences
    Media Interview
    Melaka Property
    Melaka Real Estate
    Menara Maybank
    Merdeka Generation Package
    Ministry Of Finance Malaysia
    Ministry Of Social And Family Development
    MM2H
    Mutiara Rini Sdn Bhd
    MyTOWN Shopping Centre
    National Day Rally 2019
    Negeri Sembilan Property
    Negeri Sembilan Real Estate
    Novena
    Ocean Financial Centre
    One Bukit Senyum
    One Cochrane
    Overleveraging
    Oxley Towers Kuala Lumpur City Centre
    P2P Funding
    Pan Island Link
    Park Nova
    Park Place Residences At PLQ
    Pasar Karat
    Pasar Seni MRT Station
    Pasir Gudang
    Pasir Gudang Hospital
    Pasir Ris
    Pasir Ris East
    Paya Lebar Central
    Paya Lebar Quarter
    Paya Lebar Square
    Penang Property
    Penang Real Estate
    Penang Transport Master Plan
    Pengerang Rapid Project
    Persada-johor
    Petaling-street
    Plaza-rakyat-lrt-station
    Plp-architecture
    Plq-mall
    Pr1ma
    Ptptn
    Public-relations
    Punggol
    Punggol-digital-district
    Rapid-transit-system-rts-link
    Renovation
    Selangor Property
    Selangor Real Estate
    Sengkang
    Serangoon-north
    Seri-alam-properties-sdn-bhd
    Singapore-budget-2019
    Singapore-budget-2020
    Singapore-economy
    Singapore-general-election
    Singapore Luxury Property Market
    Singapore Office Market
    Singapore Property
    Singapore Property Market
    Singapore Real Estate
    Singapore Retrenchments
    SME Co-Investment Fund III
    Sri Geylang Serai
    Suasana Iskandar Malaysia
    Sungai Buloh Kajang Line
    Sungai Buloh - Kajang Line (SBK Line)
    Sungai Buloh Serdang Putrajaya Line
    Tampines
    Tampines North
    Tanjong Katong Complex
    Tavistock
    Teck Ghee
    The Workers' Party
    Thomson East Coast Line
    Thomson-East Coast Line
    Thomson-East Coast MRT Line
    Tokyo Property Market
    Tokyo Real Estate
    Transit Oriented Development
    TREC
    TriTower Residence
    Tun Razak Exchange
    UM Land
    Universiti Kuala Lumpur
    Universiti Teknologi Mara
    URA Draft Master Plan 2014
    URA Draft Master Plan 2019
    Urban Redevelopment Authority
    US-China Trade War
    Vivian Balakrishnan
    Waterway Point
    Wisma Geylang Serai
    Woodland Regional Centre
    Woodlands Central
    Woodlands North Coast
    Woodlands North MRT Station
    Woodlands Regional Centre
    Yishun
    Y Waterway@Punggol

    RSS Feed

Picture

100 Peck Seah Street
#08-14
PS 100
Singapore (0793333)
Email: [email protected]
Phone: +65 8201 9254

What the market is saying

"Hi thank you so much. Keep updating." - Sharveena

"I bought your new book through Popular Bookfest in KLCC yesterday. I just finished my reading. I like it so much as it saved my time to search those information that I have been looking for it. Thank you for writing this book. I believed you have spent a lot of time to prepare it". - PY Chan

Want more bite-sized news?

    Subscribe Today!

Submit
  • Home
  • About
  • Blog
  • Books
  • Services
  • Media
  • Events
  • Awards/Accolades
  • Clients
  • Portfolio
  • Contact
  • Corporate Responsibility